Too extract or not to Extract, Part 2: camouflage?

Camouflage (reducing or increasing incisor prominence) vs surgery in treatment of Class II and Class III Problems

Treatment Possibilities for incorrect jaw relationship

  1. Guide growth so the deficient jaw catches up, and a normal jaw relationship is produced
    • This is the ideal treatment approach
  2. Orthodontic camouflage (making teeth fit even if jaws dont)
    • When growth guidance fails, extraction of upper premolars can help
  3. Orthognathic surgery to place the jaws in the correct position

Timing

The type of treatment chosen will obviously differ by age

  • Growth modification needs to happen when pt is still growing
  • Extraction / repositioning for camouflage needs to happen in late adolescence when we have a clear predication of the final relationship
  • surgical correction is only when growth is complete / nearly complete i.e. at the end of adolescent growth

Treatment Type as a Function of Age

  • Growth modification must be done prior to the adolescent growth spurt and is most effective when done during the growth spurt

Orthodontic Camouflage for Class II maloclussion

Class II malocclusion is the major indication for orthodontic camouflage

In Class II, the upper incisors protrude. The space to retract them is obtained by extracting the maxillary first premolars

Possible Extraction patterns:

  • Maxillary first premolars
  • Maxillary first and mandibular second premolars
  • Maxillary and mandibular first premolars

Maxillary ad mandibular premolar extraction

Done in cases where Class II elastics are used to to pull the upper incisors back and the lower molars forward! often the second mandibular premolars are done to protect the lower incisors from retraction If the lower arch is also crowded then elastics and lower first premolar extraction will be needed to maintain the position of the incisors

  • class II div 2 patients usually have a short face an deep bite.

Class II Camouflage vs Surgery

  • In ambiguous cases, it should be the patients choice

Class III Camouflage

Less successful in general

  • Retracting the lower incisors doesn’t make a protruding chin less prominent Contents
  1. A higher percentage of skeletal Class III patients will need surgeries
  2. Retracting the lower incisors is rarely indicated. Extractions are also rarely indicated

Summary

  • Camouflage is done frequently for Class II patients, especially those who have maxillary dental protrusion and mild/moderate mandibular deficiency
  • There are two main disadvantags of camouflage
    • Retracting incisors too much can result in unsatisfactory facial aesthetics
    • Loss of root length (root resoprtion) occurs more frequently in camouflage cases then it does in other cases of orthodontic treatment

Orthodontic Retention

The reasons for retention: PDL reorganization, gingival fiber effects and equilibrium changes due to growth.

Why are retainers necessary

  1. The periodontal and gingival tissues are affected by tooth movement and they require time for reorganization after an active orthodontic appliance is removed
  2. Pressure by the tongue and lips / cheeks provides force against teeth that can result in tooth movement
  3. Growth after treatment is likely to lead to adaptive changes in tooth position , this means potential instability until growth is completed even in patients who had no skeletal problem.

PDL considerations

  • peridontla ligament fibers are disorganized after ortho treatment
  • Cheek-lip/ tongue pressures won’t be balanced
  • To keep the teeth in proper position, active stabilization is required, it takes the pdl 3-4 months to do this

Gingival fiber effects

  • Elastic fibers in the gingiva are stretched as teeth are moved
  • Holding the teeth in alignment uring the rest of treatment helps with gingival fiber adaptation
    • but it takes a long time for adaptation to occur, and if teeth were irregular, at least another year after debanding is needed

Growth Effects

  • normal / late mandibular growth causes incisors to tip back so lower incisors need to be maintained until growth is completed
  • Even if growth modification has been successful, further growth will occur in the orginal pattern!
  • Relapse due to late grwoth is even more of a problem for skeeltal Class III and open bite problems

Schedule and timing of retention

  • Reorganization of the PDL requires: movement of teeth realtive to each other during chewing and the bending of alveolar bone that accompanies mastication
  • During the first 3-4 months post-treatment
    • removable reatiners are taken out to eat and worn all the rest of the time
    • if retainers are fixed they must allow movement
  • Gingival fibers required at least part-time retention for a least 12 months
  • Soft tissue (tong/lip-cheek) pressures may rquire retention unti growth ends and if enough of a change was made, may be required for ever

Typical retention Schedule

  • Full-time except during eating, for the first 3-4 mnths
  • Part-time for the next 8-9 months
  • Continue part-time until growth is complete
  • If pressures unbalanced, continue indefinitely

Discuss the indications for and management of removable vs fixed retainers

Put retention in the perspective of interaction with orthodontists about patients that you have in common