Abbott and Sunthoramoorthy 2021 - Invasive Resorption Cohort

Citation and evidence type

The lecture attributes the dataset to “An Analysis of 219 patients with External Invasive Resorption in 293 Teeth” — 2021, Abbott & Sunthoramoorthy (unpublished data). It is an unpublished clinical cohort with case-series treatment outcomes; no journal publication or full bibliographic citation is supplied.

The source spells the second surname “Sunthoramoorthy” in most headings and outcome captions, but “Sunthoramorthy” beside the class and tooth-distribution data. Both spellings are retained as a source discrepancy.

The lecture does not report the recruitment period, selection method, diagnostic criteria, follow-up schedule, or definitions for outcome labels. Potential predisposing factors are reported as associations, not established causes.

Contextual takeaway

This unpublished series of 219 patients and 293 teeth describes class-specific outcomes across varied treatments and follow-up, without a controlled comparison of efficacy.

Source-linked evidence

The cohort material appears across L9’s Epidemiology and Prevalence, Classification Systems, and Case Series Outcomes sections. The original lecture and PDF pages are linked in the metadata and page references below.

Cohort characteristics

The series includes 219 patients and 293 teeth. The lecture reports patient-level and tooth-level percentages separately.

Potential predisposing factors 1

Potential Predisposing Factor% Patients% Teeth
Unknown23.033.5
Trauma15.212.8
Orthodontics11.510.8
Restoration11.810.5
Periodontal Disease / Treatment9.68.3
Previous Root Canal Filling10.28.3
Surgery3.42.8
Bleaching3.12.5
Bruxism2.82.5
Transplanted Tooth2.22.3
Post/Crown2.22.0
Cracked Cusp1.91.5
Bridge Abutment1.21.0
Other1.21.0
Submergence0.60.5

The image immediately after Abbott’s 1994 Table 5 is captioned as that table in L9, but its contents match this 2021 predisposing-factor table. The caption mismatch is retained here.

L9 caption: Table 5, types and incidence of root resorption among 2,000 patients referred for treatment; image content is the 2021 potential-predisposing-factor table

Gender and age 1

Gender% Patients% Teeth
Male55.7%47.4%
Female44.3%52.6%
Age summaryAge (years)
Youngest11
Oldest84
Mean43.9
Median43
Mode40
Age (years)% Patients
10–199.1
20–2911.9
30–3919.6
40–4920.1
50–5922.4
60–698.7
70–795.9
> 802.3

L9 places the following uncaptioned images after the cohort demographics and multiple-site lecturer note, before its Clinical Features section. Their individual relationship to the dataset is not stated 2.

Referral categories by tooth 3

Referred AsNo. Teeth% Teeth
Resorption5318.1
Internal Resorption4816.4
External Resorption5217.7
External Invasive Resorption9331.7
Caries155.1
Another Tooth144.8
Other: Pink Tooth, Granulation Tissue, Pain, Inflammation, Radiolucency, Chronic Abscess, Infection + Resorption or Perforation, Root Defect + Perio Pocket + Inflammation, For Endodontics, Dens Invaginatus186.1
Totals293100.0

Class and tooth distributions 4

Heithersay ClassNo. Teeth% Teeth
1124.1
26020.5
310435.5
411739.9
Total293100
Tooth typeMaxillaryMandibular
Central21.86.8
Lateral5.13.1
Canine8.96.5
1st Premolar1.73.1
2nd Premolar3.84.8
1st Molar10.68.5
2nd Molar4.44.4
3rd Molar2.44.1
TOTALS58.741.3

L9 labels the class distribution as “2021 — Abbott & Sunthoramorthy (unpublished data)” and the tooth-type data as “2021 — Abbott & Sunthoramoorthy (unpublished data).”

An Analysis of 219 patients with External Invasive Resorption in 293 Teeth

An Analysis of 219 patients with External Invasive Resorption in 293 Teeth

The tooth-type row in L9 also contains a Patel classification figure; only the separate image captioned with this cohort is reproduced here.

An Analysis of 219 patients with External Invasive Resorption in 293 Teeth

Class-specific treatments and follow-up

Class 1 cases — 12 teeth (follow-up: 6 mths–6 yrs) 5

No. TeethTreatmentOutcome
1Advised ExtractionN/A
3TCA + GIC3 Stable / No More Resorption
1TCA + GIC + Endo1 No RC
2TCA + GIC + Endo (Internal Approach)2 Stable / No More Resorption
5TCA + GIC + Flap5 Stable / No More Resorption

L9 shows numbered images 1 and 2 after this table, with uncaptioned companion images:

Class 2 cases — 60 teeth (follow-up: 6 mths–10 yrs) 6

No. TeethTreatmentOutcome
7WatchResorption Continued
5Advised ExtractionN/A
20TCA + GIC1 Endo at RC, 1 Exo at RC, 16 Stable / No More Resorption, 2 No RC
15TCA + GIC + Endo12 Stable / No More Resorption, 3 No RC
2TCA + GIC + Endo (Internal Approach)2 Stable / No More Resorption
7TCA + GIC + Flap7 Stable / No More Resorption
2TCA + GIC + Flap + Endo2 Stable / No More Resorption
1TCA + GIC + Flap + Retrograde Endo1 No RC
1Pt did not proceed with treatmentN/A

L9 shows numbered images 3 and 4 and three uncaptioned companion images after this table:

Class 3 cases — 104 teeth (follow-up: 6 mths–6 yrs) 6

No. TeethTreatmentOutcome
28Watch1 Endo at RC, 2 Exo at RC, 18 Resorption continued, 1 Stable / No More Resorption, 6 No RC
25Advised ExtractionN/A
10TCA + GIC1 Resorption continued, 3 Exo at RC, 4 Stable / No More Resorption, 2 No RC
22TCA + GIC + Endo4 Exo at RC, 15 Stable / No More Resorption, 3 No RC
5TCA + GIC + Endo (Internal Approach)3 Stable / No More Resorption, 2 No RC
5TCA + GIC + Flap2 Exo at RC, 3 Stable / No More Resorption
2TCA + GIC + Flap + Endo2 Stable / No More Resorption
3TCA + GIC + Flap + Retrograde Endo1 Stable / No More Resorption, 2 No RC
1TCA + GIC + Endo + Post/Crown1 Stable / No More Resorption
1Pt did not proceed with treatmentN/A

Class 4 cases — 117 teeth (follow-up: 3 mths–21 yrs) 6

No. TeethTreatmentOutcome
24Watch1 Exo at RC, 7 Resorption continued, 2 Stable / No More Resorption, 14 No RC
91Advised ExtractionN/A
1TCA + GIC + Root Resection1 Stable / No More Resorption
1Pt did not proceed with treatmentN/A

The source abbreviates outcomes as “No RC,” “Endo at RC,” and “Exo at RC” in these treatment tables without defining RC. The later summary expands one outcome column as “No Recall / Unknown Result”; abbreviations are retained rather than silently normalized.

Root canal treatment 7

ClassNo. TeethNo. Treated for Invasive ResorptionNo. that Required Root Canal TreatmentNo. Treated via an Internal Approach% of Teeth that had Root Canal Treatment
112111227%
2604720247%
31044833569%

L9 has no Class 4 row in this summary. The images immediately after the table carry the 2021 cohort caption:

An Analysis of 219 patients with External Invasive Resorption in 293 Teeth

An Analysis of 219 patients with External Invasive Resorption in 293 Teeth

All cases — 293 teeth; follow-up 3 mths–21 yrs 7

ClassNo. TeethAdvised ExtractionAdvised WatchTreated ResorptionResorption Control With TCA TreatmentResorption Continued After TreatmentNo Recall / Unknown Result
1121 (8%)011 (92%)10 (91%)01 (1%)
2605 (8%)7 (12%)47 (78%)39 (83%)4 (9%)7 (15%)
310420 (19%)28 (27%)48 (46%)30 (63%)10 (21%)15 (31%)
411791 (78%)24 (21%)1 (0.8%)1 (100%)00

Source limitations and table checks

The lecture presents no comparator, recruitment or selection method, diagnostic protocol, or outcome definitions. The detailed Class 3 treatment entries sum to 102 teeth against the 104-tooth heading. In the all-cases summary, extraction/watch/treatment counts sum to 59/60 for Class 2, 96/104 for Class 3, and 116/117 for Class 4. The control/continued/unknown-result counts also exceed the treated totals for Classes 2 and 3; Class 1 prints “1 (1%)” for one unknown result. These values are preserved as printed and are not pooled or recalculated.

Original PDF pages

Footnotes

  1. Original L9 PDF page 10: L9 PDF p. 10. ↩ ↩2

  2. Original L9 PDF page 11: L9 PDF p. 11. ↩

  3. Original L9 PDF page 15: L9 PDF p. 15. ↩

  4. Original L9 PDF page 21: L9 PDF p. 21. ↩

  5. Original L9 PDF page 37: L9 PDF p. 37. ↩

  6. Original L9 PDF page 38: L9 PDF p. 38. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  7. Original L9 PDF page 39: L9 PDF p. 39. ↩ ↩2