Alobaid et al 2014 - Revascularization and Apexification Pilot Cohort

Contextual takeaway

L10 reports no significant root-length or root-width difference and descriptive outcomes for a 12-tooth combined Ca(OH)₂ apexification/MTA plug group and a 19-tooth repair group; this small retrospective cohort, its unequal mean follow-up, and its combined comparator establish neither superiority, inferiority, nor equivalence.

Citation and design

Radiographic and clinical outcomes of the treatment of immature permanent teeth by revascularization or apexification: a pilot retrospective cohort study. Alobaid et al. J Endod. 2014;40:1063-1070.

L10 identifies a pilot retrospective cohort of immature permanent teeth. It says the study compared Ca(OH)₂ apexification, MTA “apical plugs,” and a “repair” procedure, then combined the calcium-hydroxide and MTA plug groups because of small numbers. The lecture gives tooth counts but no patient count, age range, or allocation details.

Outcomes reported in L10

The lecture says there was no significant difference between groups for root length or width after treatment and summarizes that “repair” was “not superior to apexification.” The displayed comparison is against the combined apexification/MTA-plug group, not separate estimates for each procedure.

OutcomeCa(OH)₂ apexification + MTA “apical plug” (combined group)“Repair” procedure (“regeneration”)
Teeth; average follow-up12; 22 months19; 15 months
Survival12 (100%)18 (95%)
“Clinical success” (not defined in L10)12 (100%)15 (78%)
“Adverse events”1 (11%)8 (42%)

Adverse events reported for “repair”: re-infection (3), staining (2), re-traumatized (1), fracture (1), and pain (1). The combined apexification/MTA-plug group lists re-traumatized (1).

Source qualifications

L10 does not provide p-values. Its table lists 12 teeth in the combined group and reports 1 adverse event (11%), but does not state the denominator used for that percentage; both figures are retained as printed.

The adjacent lecturer note says “regeneration” is an inappropriate label because the procedures do not recreate normal pulp; repair may produce connective or fibrous tissue and cementum-like or bone-like hard tissue. This is lecturer framing, not a measured outcome in the cohort.

The course learning-objective summary repeats the survival and adverse-event headlines without adding a denominator or separate outcome: Dento-alveolar and Maxillofacial Trauma LOs > L10.8 - Root Development Stage and Pulp Healing.

No study-specific figure, media embed, caption, or numbered source footnote appears in the L10 Markdown block. The cited journal pages are 1063-1070.

Source lecture

L10 Dento-Alveolar Trauma 3 - Tissue Responses to Injury > Factors Affecting Healing After Trauma