Frank 1966 - Continued Apical Formation

Citation: Frank AL. Therapy for the divergent pulpless tooth by continued apical formation. J Am Dent Assoc 1966;72:87–93.

Evidence type: Historical clinical treatment report; L17 does not state the paper’s study design.

Contextual takeaway

L17 attributes to Frank a calcium-hydroxide approach for a divergent pulpless tooth that produced reported apical closure and a calcific stop for later root filling. The lecture distinguishes this barrier from continued normal root formation; current apexification teaching remains in L17’s apexification section.

Reported method and outcome

L17 frames the paper around a divergent pulpless tooth with an open apex. Its lecturer summary states that calcium hydroxide was placed in the root canal and open apex, then covered with cotton wool and a provisional restoration.1

The lecture says that reported cases showed apical closure after calcium hydroxide had been placed “for a period of time.” The resulting calcific barrier could contain bone-like, cementum-like or other calcified tissue, was not necessarily uniform, and allowed subsequent filling material to be condensed. L17 explicitly distinguishes this barrier from normal continued root formation.1

The source figure labels the materials as Ca(OH)₂, cotton fibers, zinc oxide-eugenol and zinc oxyphosphate cement. Its caption reads: “Calcium hydroxide therapy for divergent pulpless tooth. This temporary seal is to be replaced with gutta-percha root canal filling after periapical closure.”1

Frank’s excerpt in L17

“Successful endodontic treatment requires that … ing of gutta-percha or the preparation of the apex to receive an apical seal such as an alloy of silver amalgam (Fig. 1).”

“Surgical intervention, when necessary, is a complete and successful procedure. This paper is not intended to condemn the periradicular technic; however, mechanical and psychological aspects indigenous to the care of the patients who are …”

The lecture excerpt is clipped with ellipses and does not supply the missing words; they are left unfilled.1

Evidence limits

L17 supplies no case count or denominator, time to closure, comparison group or measurement/histology method, so the reported cases provide no rate or timing estimate.

Original lecture pages

The paired lecture radiographs are retained from page 8.2

Footnotes

  1. L17 original lecture PDF, page 7: page 7. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  2. L17 original lecture PDF, page 8: page 8. ↩