Heithersay 1999 - TCA Treatment Pages 96-110

Source extract from L9, Treatment Outcomes.

Citation and scope

Heithersay, G. S. Quintessence International. 1999; 30: 96-110, as listed in L9. The exact article title is not established in the lecture. L9 lists three separate Heithersay page ranges; this note covers only pp. 96-110 on treatment with TCA, curettage and restoration. L9 also says the three comprehensive publications appeared in 1990; the year mapping remains unresolved.

Evidence and methods

Evidence type: Clinical treatment series. L9 presents class-stratified five-year outcomes and attributes treatment to trichloroacetic acid (TCA), curettage and restoration. The outcomes extract does not state the study design or sample size.

Contextual takeaway: L9 reports three separate five-year outcomes by Heithersay class; all three measures are 100% in Classes 1 and 2 and lower in Classes 3 and 4, especially overall success, but the extract gives no class denominators.

Five-year outcomes

Heithersay classResorption controlTooth survivalOverall success
Class 1100 %100 %100 %
Class 2100 %100 %100 %
Class 396.8 %92.1 %77.8 %
Class 450.0 %50.0 %12.5 %

Classes shown: Class 1, Class 2, Class 3, Class 4 (Heithersay 1999).

L9 states a five-year follow-up. It reports percentages only, without class-specific denominators or definitions for resorption control, tooth survival, or overall success. The separate Abbott and Sunthoramoorthy 2021 unpublished dataset in L9 contains 293 teeth but is a different cohort and does not provide denominators for these Heithersay results.

L9 retains the class-specific clinical interpretation and management guidance, including the Class 3 and Class 4 comments, and the adjacent Heithersay class illustration. This note carries the study method summary and reported outcome measures.

Source lecture page 1

Footnotes

  1. Original PDF page 36: L9 Resorption 5 - External Invasive, p.36. ↩