Maltz et al 2012 - Selective Caries Removal

Citation and evidence type

Maltz et al. Randomized trial of partial vs. stepwise caries removal: 3-year follow-up. Journal of Dental Research. 2012 Nov;91(11):1026–31. doi: 10.1177/0022034512460403. PMID 22983407.

Evidence type: Randomized clinical trial comparing partial caries removal (PCR) with stepwise caries removal (SW), as labeled in the L6 trial block. The source lecture is L6 Vital Pulp Treatment 1.

Contextual takeaway

At 3 years, success (no failure from the causes listed below) was higher after one-stage partial caries removal than after stepwise removal: 91% vs 69%, adjusted p = .004. Attrition was high (40 PCR, 46 SW lost).

Trial flow and follow-up

L6 reports clinical and radiographic selection and invitation to participate for n = 299, with no exclusions after that selection. The randomized allocation and year-three follow-up were:

GroupAllocatedPorto AlegreBrasiliaLost by year 3Analyzed at year 3
Partial caries removal (PCR)152787440112
Stepwise caries removal (SW)147767146101

The lecture says 213 teeth (112 PCR, 101 SW) were followed at year three. Its figure notes list panels “A B C D, E F G, Post-op 9 mo, H I” and scale markers of 1 mm and 350 μm.

Outcomes reported in the detailed block

The L6 text describes a Weibull survival analysis in Fig. 2A. After adjustment for other potential predictors, year-three success was 91% for PCR and 69% for SW (p = .004).

GroupCauses of failure reported in L6
PCRPulpitis (4); pulp necrosis (1)
SWPulpitis (11); necrosis (5); pulp exposure followed by endodontic treatment (2); osteitis (1); tooth extraction (1); tooth fracture (1)

For SW, the comparison of teeth that had completed treatment (n = 84) with those that had not (n = 17) reported 88% and 13% success, respectively (p < .001, Fig. 2B).

The next L6 sentence starts, “The Weibull regression model with individual level frailty was”, but the extracted Markdown ends the sentence there.

Separate summaries in L6

The ESE position-statement passage reports three-year success of 90% for one-stage selective removal and 70% for stepwise excavation, defining success as absence of clinical symptoms and maintenance of pulp health. It notes that many stepwise cases did not return for the second visit, “making comparison”; the L6 sentence ends at that point.1

Lecturer (audio) summarised the trial as showing no significant difference; this does not match the published adjusted result. The lecturer also cautioned that about one-third were lost to follow-up and their outcomes are unknown.

Guidance and local teaching context

L6 presents the ESE position as supporting one-stage selective removal to soft or firm dentine and two-stage stepwise excavation for deep lesions in asymptomatic teeth or teeth with signs and symptoms of reversible pulpitis. Its statement also describes complete/non-selective removal as no longer the treatment of choice for deep caries, citing a recent consensus that considers it overtreatment.

The lecture contrasts this with an AAE position favoring complete caries removal. The adjacent Caries Management (Contrasting View) passage says full removal eliminates infected tissues and permits inspection of pulp conditions under magnification when exposure occurs; it warns that retained caries compromises assessment of inflammation or necrosis. The audio questions whether selective/partial and non-selective/complete wording itself makes one approach sound more acceptable. These are lecture guidance and framing, separate from the trial outcomes above.

Citation distinction

L6 repeats the J Dent 2020 Sep:100:103430 citation around the 2012 trial material, without authors or a title in this extract. That citation remains unresolved and is kept separate; proximity alone does not establish that it is part of the Maltz trial.

Original lecture pages

The ESE passage is on original PDF page 33. The trial block and its figure material link to pages 34–36.234

Footnotes

  1. Original PDF page 33: L6 Vital Pulp Treatment 1, p. 33. ↩

  2. Original PDF page 34: L6 Vital Pulp Treatment 1, p. 34. ↩

  3. Original PDF page 35: L6 Vital Pulp Treatment 1, p. 35. ↩

  4. Original PDF page 36: L6 Vital Pulp Treatment 1, p. 36. ↩